Press "Enter" to skip to content

UP Police slammed over dealing with of Hathras gangrape; ‘being pressured’, says sufferer’s household – India News , Firstpost

The sufferer, a 19-year-old Dalit lady was gangraped Yogi Adityanath-ruled Uttar Pradesh’s Hathras allegedly by 4 males on 14 September. After her situation deteriorated, she was referred to Delhi’s Safdarjung hospital the place she breathed her final on Tuesday

The Uttar Pradesh Police’s seemingly bungled dealing with of the Hathras gangrape and homicide has come underneath the scanner with many, each within the press and on social media, questioning why the physique of the Dalit teen was rapidly burned in the midst of the evening and expressing skepticism on the police’s declare that there may be ‘no proof of rape’.

The sufferer, a 19-year-old Dalit lady was gang-raped in Uttar Pradesh’s Hathras allegedly by 4 males on 14 September. After her situation deteriorated, she was referred to Delhi’s Safdarjung hospital the place she breathed her final on Tuesday.

Meanwhile, a Lucknow bench of the Allahabad High Court on Thursday issued summons to the Uttar Pradesh extra chief secretary, director common of police and extra director common of police, telling them to be current earlier than the court docket on 12 October to clarify the case.

The court docket has additionally informed media homes similar to Indian Express, The Times of IndiaAajTakNDTV, to supply the fabric and content material on the premise of which they’ve reported on the cremation of the Dalit rape sufferer.

No rape declare finds few takers  

Uttar Pradesh ADG Prashant Kumar, talking to PTI on Thursdaymentioned, “The report of the Forensic Science Lab clearly says samples did not have sperm. It makes clear that there was no rape or gang rape.”

But consultants informed NDTV that the samples have been collected days after the incident — which occurred on 14 September —  and sperm would thus not be current within the report.

A scientific officer at a authorities forensic division, who didn’t want to be named, informed NDTV, “The post-mortem report mentions old healed injuries to her private parts, though how old is not mentioned. The injuries would have healed during her medical treatment. The report does not commit to rape as it’s not the cause of death and a serological examination report is awaited.”

Earlier on Thursday, Hathras superintendent of police Vikrant Vir was quoted as saying, “The medical report from the Aligarh Muslim University Medical College mentions that there were injuries but it does not confirm forced sexual intercourse. They are waiting for a report of the forensics. As of now, doctors say that they’re not confirming rape.”

It must be famous although that as per a 2013 verdict of the Supreme Court and up to date amendments, Section 375, which defines rape, was widened to incorporate acts aside from forcible peno-vaginal penetration or sexual activity.

The Uttar Pradesh Police’s claims within the Hathras case have additionally been met with skepticism after it was reported that the police, within the wee hours of Thursday morning forcibly took the teenager’s physique and cremated it.


The household reportedly begged that the police enable them to take her physique and carry out final rites the following morning however couldn’t even get a final glimpse of the teenager, as they have been locked of their house.

A chunk in The Telegraph identified that such a tactic is often employed by the police in circumstances of the militants’ funerals and is commonly employed to keep away from flare-ups.

An uncle of the 19-year-old sufferer informed the newspaper he was standing outdoors the lady’s house when “some policemen grabbed me and forcibly took me to the cremation ground and shot a video to show I had attended the funeral”.

He mentioned that after putting the physique on the pyre “the policemen poured a liquid from a plastic container on the pyre and burnt the body”. He added that no holy water ritual or mukhagni (a hearth ritual) was achieved.

“People were protesting at various places along the highway in Hathras. The police clandestinely cremated her, instead of handing the body over, to prevent the funeral triggering an outpouring of emotion and anti-government protests,” the sufferer’s elder brother informed The Telegraph.

Local law enforcement officials, nonetheless, informed PTI the cremation was carried out “as per the wishes of the family”.

ADG Kumar’s menace of authorized motion in opposition to these he accused of ‘twisting the matter to stir caste-based pressure’ did no favours for the Uttar Pradesh’s Police’s credibility within the eyes of many.

NC Asthana, retired IPS officer and former DGP Kerala, informed The Wire it’s incorrect to low cost the likelihood rape on this case.

“According to the definition of rape as amended by the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 2013, penetration of the vagina by the penis within the typical sense of intercourse is by no means essential to represent the offence of rape. Now, insertion, to any extent, of any object or part of the physique into the vaginal urethra, or anus of a girl additionally constitutes rape.

“’To any extent’ is the critical part. It means that the slightest contact with the concerned part would also make for rape,” he mentioned.

Asthana additional informed The Wire that outdated tears in a girl’s hymen, because the report suggests, are of “little consequence” on the subject of the offense. 

“It is well known that the hymen can be ruptured due to various types of physical activities. It therefore does not matter whether the victim was a virgin or not. Once again, the law on this is absolutely clear,” Asthana additional informed The Wire.

Allahabad HC takes suo moto discover

Taking suo moto cognisance, the Allahabad bench, whereas summoning prime officers, additionally directed the Hathras district Justice of the Peace and senior superintendent of police to seem earlier than it.

The bench informed all officers to return ready with all of the related materials and paperwork to apprise the court docket of their variations of the incident.

The court docket, which appeared particularly upset over the police cremating the teenager’s physique in a single day allegedly forcibly in Hathras with out her mum or dad’s consent, additionally directed officers to apprise the bench of the most recent standing of the probe into the alleged gang-rape and homicide case.

The bench additionally requested the late teen’s mum or dad to return to the court docket to apprise it of their model of the incident and ordered the Hathras district administration to rearrange for his or her journey to the court docket.

Meanwhile, the household of the sufferer on Thursday accused the district administration of pressuring them in opposition to “repeatedly changing” their assertion and demanded a CBI probe.  The father of the Dalit teen, claimed that he was “pressured” into going to a police station the place the district Justice of the Peace and police officers made three members of his household signal some doc.

‘Want CBI probe,’ says rape sufferer’s father

“But we are not satisfied with this. My daughter’s case should be probed by the CBI and monitored by a Supreme Court judge. We are under pressure from officials and confined to our home while the media has also been disallowed from meeting us,” the sufferer’s father mentioned in a purported video shared by Congress chief Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on Twitter.

The growth got here as a video surfaced purportedly exhibiting Hathras district Justice of the Peace Praveen Kumar Laxkar assembly the household at their house, the place he allegedly requested the girl’s father to “reconsider” if he needs to stay with the assertion or change it.

“You mustn’t destroy your credibility. About the media, I have to let you know, half of them have left at present… the opposite half would go away by tomorrow morning… two or 4 extra days perhaps. Only we’re standing by your aspect, alright. Now, it’s as much as you whether or not you need to change your assertion repeatedly or not…,” Laxkar tells the sufferer’s father in response to the video on social media.

A lady member of the household claimed they have been being pressured by the district Justice of the Peace and feared “these people now won’t let us live here”, in response to one other purported video.

Firstpost has not independently verified the authenticity of the movies.

“They have made random movies of mom’s statements. Soon after the incident, the state of affairs was such that we have been talking something that got here to our minds… But now they (administration) will not allow us to dwell right here anymore. This DM is a trickster, he’s pressuring us. Says we aren’t dependable, we’re altering our assertion. They requested our father and informed him that we lose credibility if we modify the assertion, we (directors) can be despatched to another place,” the sobbing girl alleged, as per PTI.

Dalit girl gang-raped in Balrampur, say stories

On Thursday, one other gangrape got here to gentle with stories saying {that a} 22-year-old Dalit girl died two days in the past after being raped allegedly by two males in UP’s Balrampur district.

Balrampur superintendent of police Dev Ranjan Verma, quoting the sufferer’s household, mentioned the girl, who labored with a non-public agency, returned house in a critical situation on Tuesday.

The lady regarded dazed and had an intravascular cannula, medically generally known as Vigo and used for administering injection or different fluids within the physique, inserted in her fingers.

She was rushed to a close-by hospital, however died on the way in which, mentioned the SP. When the matter was reported to the police from the hospital, the dad and mom alleged that their daughter was gang-raped, SP Verma mentioned.

Caste discrimination, a day by day actuality

As per one other article in The Wire, within the Uttar Pradesh village the place the 14 September gangrape occurred caste discrimination is an on a regular basis actuality.

As per the piece, of the a number of hundred households within the village, solely 4 households are Dalit. There are round fifteen Brahmin households and round 100 Thakur households.

A  couple, who dwell in the home adjoining to victims informed The Wire, that the [Thakurs] within the village don’t shrink back from violence. The  couple narrated how almost 30 Thakurs assembled to beat their little one after he by accident touched a packet of jaggery being carried by a toddler from the Thakur caste.

The little one  was unhurt as a result of his grandmother provided double the quantity to purchase contemporary jaggery.

FIR in opposition to Rahul, Opposition slams UP authorities

The police in Uttar Pradesh’s Gautam Buddh Nagar on Thursday mentioned it has lodged an FIR in opposition to Congress leaders Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and round 200 different occasion staff underneath The Epidemic Diseases Act for not sustaining social distancing and never carrying face masks.

The FIR was lodged underneath Indian Penal Code sections 188 (disobedience to order duly promulgated by public servant), 269 (unlawfully or negligently spreading an infection of any illness harmful to life), 270 (malignant act prone to unfold an infection of illness harmful to life) and underneath part three of the Epidemic Diseases Act, the police mentioned.

Rahul and Priyanka have been  arrested after they have been stopped from marching in direction of Hathras, with Rahul falling down in in a melee after police tried to cease him and his supporters from continuing on the Yamuna Expressway. The Gandhis have been then taken away in a police jeep, detained and later launched.

According to stories, Rahul questioned the senior UP cops as to underneath which regulation was he being stopped by them, as he needed to stroll alone in direction of Hathras to fulfill the rape sufferer’s household.

“Can you tell me under which law can you stop me from marching towards Hathras?” he requested.

“I want to go alone to Hathras and on what basis can you arrest me?” he requested, to which the cops informed him that he had violated Section 188 of the IPC of disobeying the orders promulgated by the federal government through the pandemic.

Congress chief Randeep Surjrewala put out a video together with a tweet exhibiting Rahul allegedly being roughed up as he marched ahead on the Yamuna Expressway. Pictures of him falling down within the melee have been additionally shared by the Congress.

“Lala Lajpat Rai had said that every blow of a stick on my body would prove to be the last nail in the coffin of the British Raj. “The sticks on Rahul ji and Priyanka ji’s convoy may even show to be the final nail within the coffin of the Yogi authorities,” Surjewala mentioned in a tweet in Hindi.

Congress chief P Chidambaram additionally alleged that not one of the nation’s legal guidelines appeared to use to the police. “UP police is a law into itself. None of the laws of the country seem to apply to it,” he alleged. “What is wrong if the leaders of a political party protest against a gruesome crime and wish to visit the victim’s family,” he requested on Twitter.

Chidambaram mentioned the 2 leaders weren’t violent, they didn’t carry arms and so they have been lodging a peaceable protest.

“Why should the police stop them from protesting peacefully? Why should the UP police arrest the two leaders and take them away?”

“I hope the court where the leaders will be produced will release them,” he mentioned.

The Congress’ Odisha unit on Thursday lashed out on the police in Adityanath-ruled Uttar Pradesh for its “undemocratic and shameful”.

West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee, terming the Hathras gangrape as “barbaric and shameful”, mentioned the “forceful cremation” of the sufferer has uncovered those that use lofty promise and slogans to hunt votes.

“Have no words to condemn the barbaric and shameful incident at Hathras involving a young Dalit girl. My deepest condolences to the family. More shameful is the forceful cremation without the family’s presence or consent, exposing those who use slogans and lofty promises for votes,” Banerjee mentioned on Twitter.

Raising questions on the regulation and order state of affairs in Uttar Pradesh, BSP chief Mayawati demanded that the management must be modified or President’s Rule be imposed within the state.

“In the wake of the regulation and order state of affairs within the state and the flood of crimes in opposition to ladies, the Central Government ought to change Yogi Adityanath with some ‘kaabil’ (succesful) individual and if this isn’t attainable, President’s Rule must be imposed within the state,” Mayawati mentioned.

“I need to say to Adityanath that you’re born from the womb of a girl. You ought to contemplate the sisters and daughters of others as your sister and daughter. If you’re unable to guard them, it’s best to resign,” she asserted.

With inputs from PTI

Find newest and upcoming tech devices on-line on Tech2 Gadgets. Get know-how information, devices opinions & rankings. Popular devices together with laptop computer, pill and cellular specs, options, costs, comparability.

Be First to Comment

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    %d bloggers like this: