Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Motive For Mamata’s Letter To Sonia Gandhi, Other Party Leaders



Have Opposition leaders lastly realised {that a} single get together cannot cease the BJP juggernaut, and to dislodge the BJP, and for their very own survival, it is very important come collectively? In the seventh yr of Modi’s rule and smack in the midst of the very high-profile election in Bengal, Mamata Banerjee has written a letter to all main Opposition leaders, exhorting them to come back collectively to avoid wasting democracy within the nation. In her letter, with out mincing phrases, she has written that the BJP, led by Modi, is hellbent on ending the Opposition and establishing a one-party, authoritarian rule within the nation. To assist her argument she has enumerated seven factors.

I’m positive that there will probably be questions as to why she has written a letter, which seeks unity amongst events that embody these she is preventing in Bengal – just like the Congress, at a time when she ought to be focusing her vitality on registering a victory for her get together within the state election. She is in center of a really powerful battle not simply to retain Bengal but in addition for her personal constituency, Nandigram, which she is contesting towards her one-time protege, Suvendu Adhikari. It is just not a provided that she’s going to win. The BJP has unleashed unimaginable fireplace energy to unseat her. In latest reminiscence, I can’t recall having seen such an aggressive marketing campaign in any meeting election. The BJP’s technique of dividing Bengal on communal strains crosses all limits. Mamata Banerjee has been known as ‘anti-Hindu’, somebody who is barely involved about Muslims. She has been known as names like ‘Begum’ Mamata, ‘Khala’ Mamata, ‘Fufu’ Mamata, and so on. Muslims are overtly known as ‘Pakistanis’ and it has been propagated that “Hindu women will not be safe if she wins elections.” To show her Hindu credentials, Mamata Banerjee resorted to reciting the ‘Chandi Path’ and declaring it’s a ritual she performs day by day as “a Brahmin girl”. She additionally introduced to the world that she belongs to the Shandilya Gotra.

Her critics may argue that Mamata, anxious about dropping the Bengal election, is searching for cooperation from opposition events to shore up her place in Bengal – as of tomorrow, two of eight phases of voting will probably be accomplished – and that since she will’t enchantment on to the Congress and Left, whom she is preventing in Bengal, she has chosen a circuitous route. But it’s untimely and baseless to imagine she is on weak floor in Bengal. Secondly, for the Bengal election, she already has the assist of a number of events to whom the letter is addressed together with these headed by Akhilesh Yadav, Sharad Pawar and Arvind Kejriwal.

Mamata Banerjee

It can also be rumoured that she has a secret understanding with the Congress to not weaken the Trinamool, and if want be, switch their votes to one another. There isn’t any unbiased affirmation however Rahul and Priyanka Gandhi not visiting Bengal offers credence to this data.

In Bengal, the Congress has solid an alliance with the Left, however they’ve been unable to show the state right into a tricornered contest; as a substitute, they might find yourself serving to the BJP by splitting the Muslim vote. The Left, it appears, is just not prepared to forgive Mamata Banerjee for ending its rule in 2011. CPM leaders have been saying that to avoid wasting West Bengal, Mamata and the BJP each need to be defeated. But not like Mamata, who has prior to now allied with the BJP, the Left can’t accomplish that. So it can don’t have any possibility however to associate with the anti-BJP alliance being proposed by her.

There is little question that if Mamata Banerjee wins this elections, and if she wins comfortably, she may emerge as essentially the most highly effective chief within the Opposition camp; if she loses, the hope of stopping the BJP on the nationwide stage will dissipate into skinny air and it may pave the way in which for ‘one-party, authoritarian rule’ within the nation. If the BJP wins, its victory will show to be an important experiment in India’s electoral historical past: that Hindutva alone has the ability to make the BJP victorious even in a state the place, until a number of years in the past, it was a non-entity; that Hindutva as an agenda and as a motion is unstoppable, at the least for now; that secular politics is lifeless and buried; that Muslims as a political entity, regardless of their giant quantity, don’t have any that means in India’s electoral course of. And if that occurs, the entire edifice of secular-representative democracy will collapse.


Suvendu Adhikari

Mamata’s letter needs to be seen on this context. Among the seven factors she has raised is the matter of Arvind Kejriwal’s authorities being diminished to a toothless, powerless administration with the latest laws pushed by parliament by the centre. The laws promotes the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi above that of an elected authorities. She has additionally referred in her letter to Opposition governments, leaders, events being hounded by central authorities businesses. She has been troubled by the Governor of West Bengal, who has misplaced no alternative to discredit the federal government in West Bengal. She is just not too off the mark when she questions his conduct. The Governors in different opposition-ruled states aren’t any higher and infrequently, their conduct seems to be extra so of a BJP office-bearer than of the workplace that they maintain.

The debate on the centre-state relationship is now not legitimate. The thought of cooperative federalism, envisaged by Prime Minister Modi himself, has lengthy been deserted. It is anticipated that states need to comply with the diktats of the centre, and If they dare disobey, penalties embody central businesses all of a sudden getting very lively and making their lives hell.

A democracy is outlined not solely by the federal government, but in addition by the dynamism of the Opposition, which has by no means been so weak. If India is in peril of leaning in the direction of one-party, authoritarian rule, the Opposition is equally to be blamed. There was a time, simply after independence, when Nehru was a colossus, the Congress was a like a leviathan, and the opposition was nowhere to be counted, however stalwarts like Ram Manohar Lohia, JP, Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Communist leaders didn’t give up. During Indira Gandhi’s time, when the Opposition was weak, she used her brute majority to crush establishments which lastly led to the Emergency in 1975. A weak opposition is the primary signal of an authoritarian regime.

The Opposition within the final seven years has upset the folks of the nation. It’s not that they didn’t make any effort prior to now to come back collectively, however every time, they acted out of their particular person vested pursuits. If at the moment, Mamata has realised the seriousness of the matter, and if her name can deliver different leaders collectively, it is not going to solely assist the Opposition to achieve floor however may also strengthen democracy and make the federal government on the centre accountable. A variety of heavy lifting is required. 

(Ashutosh is Author and Editor, 

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed inside this text are the non-public opinions of the creator. The details and opinions showing within the article don’t replicate the views of NDTV and NDTV doesn’t assume any duty or legal responsibility for a similar.

Be First to Comment

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    %d bloggers like this: