Press "Enter" to skip to content

Bhutan Denies Chinese Incursion. Blatant Untruth, Say Global Observers



China’s Pangda village, 2.5 km inside Bhutan, is 9 km from 2017 India-China Doklam face-off website

New Delhi:

Bhutan in the present day denied stories that China has constructed a village greater than 2 kilometres inside Bhutanese territory close to the contested Doklam plateau, regardless of clear satellite tv for pc imagery and detailed map places on the contrary.

Maps bearing the official seal of the Bhutan authorities, accessed by NDTV, additionally point out that this new Chinese settlement lies effectively inside Bhutan’s current declare traces.


Location of China’s Pangda village, close to Doklam plateau, superimposed on official map of Bhutan. Source: National Statistics Bureau, Government of Bhutan.

Reacting to NDTV’s report that highlighted what seems to be a transparent Chinese incursion, Major General Vetsop Namgyel, Bhutan’s Ambassador to India, stated, “There is no Chinese village inside Bhutan.”

On whether or not Bhutan and China had reached any understanding on realigning the border within the contested space, the Ambassador stated he “does not comment on border matters.” He did, nonetheless, verify that Bhutan and China had been concerned in border talks, a course of slowed down by the coronavirus pandemic.

On Thursday, Shen Shiwei, a senior producer with CGTN, China’s state-sponsored media, showcased a number of photos of the village which contains a street and chalets by the facet of a river and tweeted, “Now, we have permanent residents living in the newly established Pangda village. It’s along the valley, 35 km south to Yadong country. Here is a map to show the location.”

International observers, together with Nathan Ruser, a satellite tv for pc imagery analyst with the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, responded to Shen’s tweets by highlighting that the situation of the Chinese village indicated a transparent breach of Bhutan’s sovereignty.

“Here’s a CGTN news producer openly admitting that China has occupied and now populated part of a sovereign country,” tweeted Mr Ruser. “This Pangda village has been constructed (as shown by the included map) 2.5 km beyond Bhutan’s international border. China now baselessly claims about 12 per cent of Bhutan,” Mr Ruser stated.

Responding to this morning’s denial by Bhutan, Mr Ruser tweeted: “Weird statement considering there’s satellite imagery and extensive photos from the ground of this village inside Bhutan, 9 kilometres from the Doklam face-off site. Seems like a blatant untruth to me.”

Other worldwide observers, together with Detresfa, who works extensively on Chinese developments throughout the Sino-Indian border area, have independently tweeted the precise map location of Pangda village. Satellite imagery of the situation exactly matches photos of the now-completed village which have been shared on social media in China.


Precise location and satellite tv for pc imagery of China’s Pangda village, positioned 2.5 kilometres inside Bhutan’s territory

The new Chinese village lies in an space of immense sensitivity to India.


In 2017, the armies of India and China had confronted off at a website on the Doklam plateau, simply 9 km to the west of this settlement. Beijing insists that Doklam is Chinese territory, whereas India backs Bhutan’s declare over the realm. India has traditionally been a net-security supplier of Bhutan with each nations having agreements to intently cooperate with one another on problems with nationwide significance.

On June 30, 2017, on the top of the standoff between Indian and Chinese forces, New Delhi accused Beijing of violating a 2012 settlement by unilaterally altering the established order of the tri-junction boundary within the area. New Delhi believes this tri-junction between India, China and Bhutan lies north of the 2017 faceoff website at Doka La – on the western fringe of the Doklam plateau – whereas Beijing believes it lies effectively to the south at Mount Gipmochi as per an 1890 treaty.

For India, any Chinese transfer to encroach additional south within the Doklam plateau area would place it perilously near the slender and probably susceptible Siliguri hall, the slender sliver of land which hyperlinks India’s north-eastern states with the remainder of the nation.

It is for that reason that any realignment of the boundary between Bhutan and China throughout the broader Doklam space would sound alarm bells in New Delhi. And but, the Bhutanese denial of any Chinese encroachment on their territory is an indicator that that is exactly what could also be occurring.

In a sequence of tweets this morning, Tenzing Lamsang, editor of The Bhutanese newspaper, identified, “Bhutan and China recognise the 269 sqkm in the west and 495 sqkm in north-central Bhutan as [being] disputed and so while there are maximalist claim lines from both sides, there is no mutually accepted international border there yet.”

India would need to know whether or not dialogue between Bhutan and China has meant that the tiny village of Pangda, broadly showcased by Chinese state media, is now a part of territory that until not too long ago belonged to Bhutan – however might now be Chinese.

Be First to Comment

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    %d bloggers like this: